In Malaysia, when discussing luxury MPVs, whether one likes them or not, the vehicles that invariably come to mind are the Toyota Alphard and Vellfire.
From time to time, names like the Mercedes-Benz Vito and Lexus LM may cross the lips of those with a penchant for the luxurious, but ultimately, the Alphard and Vellfire are consistently top of the list.
This is hardly surprising, as this writer is certain that both models are indeed impressive and worthwhile purchases. However, if you are seeking something different, their closest competitor, the Kia Carnival, proves to be a worthy alternative.
Why, you may ask?
First and foremost, it’s about size. In this writer’s opinion, those who purchase MPVs often rank size as one of the highest criteria before making a decision.
Therefore, if you desire a vehicle that is spacious and roomy, look no further than the Carnival, which is appreciably larger than the Alphard/Vellfire.
For comparison, the Carnival measures 5,155 mm in length, 1,995 mm in width, and 1,740 mm in height, with a wheelbase of 3,090 mm.
In contrast, the Alphard/Vellfire duo is somewhat smaller, with a length of 5,010 mm (5,005 mm for the Vellfire), a width of 1,850 mm, a height of 1,950 mm, and a wheelbase of 3,000 mm.
In terms of design, the Carnival boasts a sportier appearance that resembles a sleek long wagon due to its lower and wider body shape. This is further accentuated by 19-inch black alloy wheels replacing the previous 18-inch versions.
While the Toyota MPVs are not unattractive, their boxy design does come across as somewhat conventional when positioned alongside their Korean counterpart.
As for the interior, this writer can confidently assert that the quality and features offered by the Carnival are on par with those of the Japanese models, even though the price difference among these vehicles can be as much as RM300,000.
It’s true that the Alphard/Vellfire feel a touch more luxurious due to their Lexus-like touches and higher-grade materials such as genuine Nappa leather upholstery. However, the Carnival still impresses.
The materials covering the seats, dashboard, and door panels feel sufficiently high-quality, as do all the physical buttons present throughout.
The Carnival is replete with features, including a 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster, a 12.3-inch touchscreen, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, a three-zone climate control system, heating and ventilation functions for the front seats, and a Bose audio system with 12 speakers.
Moreover, the High variant of the Carnival is now equipped with Blind Spot View Monitor (BVM) that displays video feed from the side mirror cameras on the digital instrument cluster, a feature that can be activated when you use the turn signals.
In summary, this writer can confidently say that the quality and features provided by the Carnival justify its price tag of almost RM250,000.
The unit that this writer recently test drove was the eight-seat variant featuring a 2-3-3 configuration. The centre seat in the second row is larger enough for adult passengers, and when not in use, it can fold down to create a small table complete with two cup holders.
What’s even more interesting is that this seat can be rotated backwards to face the third-row seats or can be completely removed if desired.
For any MPV, the best seat in the house is usually in the back, and the Carnival does not disappoint in this regard, ensuring passenger comfort with its individual climate control for the rear, as well as retractable sunshades and a sunroof.
Additionally, children need not dispute over charging points for their gadgets, as every seat in the Carnival comes with its own USB port.
It is common for three-row vehicles to have limited cargo space when all seats are in use, but with the Carnival, this is not a concern, as there is a generous, deep storage area located beneath the third-row seats.
Now, how does it perform on the road?
The Carnival is powered by a Smartstream 2.2-litre turbodiesel engine, paired with an eight-speed automatic transmission that drives the front wheels.
This engine generates 202 PS at 3,800 rpm and an impressive 440 Nm of torque, available from as low as 1,750 rpm. While the 2.4-litre turbo engine in the Alphard offers slightly more horsepower, the Carnival’s torque advantage (10 Nm more) does not go unnoticed.
As expected from a diesel engine, the torque is readily available in the lower rpm range, making the Carnival feel smooth from a standstill. In fact, its acceleration is fairly smooth and quick, which is not something you can always say about a vehicle weighing close to two tonnes.
On the highway, the engine remains exceptionally quiet. Should you find yourself needing to overtake, there’s no need for concern over power since it consistently feels adequate, even in Normal mode.
The gearbox is responsive, allowing you to quickly accelerate everytime the accelerator pedal is depressed. It also promptly downshifts to deliver the necessary power for easy overtaking.
With the recent diesel subsidy rationalisation, some may harbour concerns regarding the Carnival’s fuel consumption.
For your information, this writer recorded a fuel efficiency of around 15 km/l or 6.7 l/100 km during a mixed driving cycle that included both urban and highway conditions.
The Carnival boasts a 72-litre fuel tank, meaning that theoretically, the vehicle could be driven nearly 1,080 km before needing to refuel.
If you’re paying full price for diesel at RM3.35 per litre, a complete fill-up would cost approximately RM241.20. Is it worthwhile to spend RM241.20 for a driving range exceeding 1,000 km? That’s for you to decide.
Lastly, the Carnival’s suspension tuning and NVH (noise, vibration, and harshness) are noteworthy. The suspension is relatively soft, allowing for a confident ride over uneven surfaces without the constant need to apply the brakes.
Nevertheless, there is something about this suspension setup that instils a sense of confidence and stability, especially at higher speeds. This is what makes the MPV enjoyable to drive fast.
The NVH aspect has been carefully addressed, ensuring that as a passenger, you experience a comfortable journey, with wind and tyre noise significantly minimised. The sound of the diesel engine is only noticeable if you stand outside the vehicle.
In conclusion, there is little more that this writer can say about the Carnival except that it is exceptionally good, enjoyable to drive, and packed to the brim with features and tech to meet the needs of buyers in this segment. What’s even better is that its competitive pricing makes it accessible to a broader range of potential MPV buyers.
However, it cannot be denied that the rationalisation of diesel subsidy may lead some to reconsider their decision to purchase the Carnival.
But, for this writer, if you are in a position to spend over RM200,000 on a large MPV, you are likely capable of managing the fuel costs without subsidy.
Kia Carnival 8-Seater High Specifications
Price: RM245,888
Engine: Smartstream 2.2-litre, four-cylinder turbodiesel
Gearbox: 8-speed automatic
Power: 202 PS @ 3,800 rpm
Torque: 440 Nm @ 1,750 rpm